HP, one of the world’s largest printer manufacturers, is facing a lawsuit from two of its customers who claim that the company intentionally disabled the scanning and faxing functions of their all-in-one printers when they ran out of ink. The plaintiffs allege that HP did not inform them of this feature when they bought the printers, and that it violated the warranty and consumer protection laws.
The lawsuit was filed in 2020 by David Leacraft and James Childress, who own HP OfficeJet Pro 6968 and HP OfficeJet 5255 printers, respectively. They say that they bought the printers for their scanning and faxing capabilities, but they were surprised to find out that they could not use these functions without ink. They argue that HP’s conduct is “particularly egregious” because it “intentionally disabled features that were unrelated to printing, such as scanning and faxing, which do not require ink.”
The plaintiffs also claim that HP did not provide any option to override this feature, and that they were forced to buy expensive HP-branded ink cartridges to restore the functionality of their devices. They accuse HP of engaging in “anticompetitive and unfair business practices” and seek damages and injunctive relief.
The lawsuit was initially dismissed by a federal judge in California in 2021, who ruled that the plaintiffs did not suffer any harm or injury from HP’s actions. The judge said that the plaintiffs could have used alternative methods to scan or fax their documents, such as using a smartphone app or a third-party service.
However, the plaintiffs filed an amended complaint with more evidence and arguments, such as HP’s own patents and manuals that contradict its claims. They also cited a similar lawsuit against Canon, another printer maker, that was allowed to proceed by a different judge.
The judge then reconsidered his decision and denied HP’s motion to dismiss the case in 2023, allowing it to go to trial. The judge rejected HP’s argument that the plaintiffs did not suffer any injury, saying that it was “akin to telling someone who purchased a car with a sunroof that they have no injury because they can still drive the car without using the sunroof.” The judge also found that the plaintiffs had sufficiently alleged that HP’s representations were “likely to deceive a reasonable consumer.”
The lawsuit is one of the many legal battles that printer manufacturers are facing over their ink policies. Many consumers have complained about the high cost and low quality of printer ink, and some have resorted to using cheaper third-party cartridges or refill kits. However, printer makers have tried to prevent this by using various methods, such as firmware updates, digital rights management (DRM), and chip authentication.
Some experts have criticized these practices as unethical and harmful to the environment. They argue that printer makers are exploiting their market power and locking consumers into their proprietary ink systems. They also say that printer makers are wasting resources and creating unnecessary electronic waste by disabling perfectly functional devices.
The trial date for the HP lawsuit has not been set yet, but it is expected to be a landmark case for the printer industry. The plaintiffs are represented by Steve Berman, a prominent attorney who has handled several class-action lawsuits against big tech companies. Berman said that “HP’s actions are not only wrong but flat-out deceptive.”
Relevant articles:
– Judge denies HP’s request to dismiss printer lockdown suit, The Register, Aug 11, 2023
– Canon is getting away with printers that won’t scan sans ink — but HP might pay, The Verge, Aug 11, 2023
– Lawsuit claiming HP all-in-one printers are defective can proceed, MSN, Aug 11, 2023
– HP is unfairly restricting All-in-One printers’ scanning functionality, Techzine, Aug 14, 2023